Tuesday, September 29, 2015

Argument for the Non-Existence of God (No. 3)

From Objectivism



P 1 ) The primacy of existence maintains that existence (or "existents") exist (in a mind-independent reality). 
P 2 ) Consciousness cannot occur unless it has something (existents) to be conscious of, and so is secondary and subordinate to the primacy of existence.
P 3 ) The conscious only has this relationship and it is not possible for a conscious to create or otherwise change existents through only its conscious will (through only "thought").  A consciousness does not hold metaphysical primacy over reality.
P 4 ) "God" is ultimately defined in many religions as a consciousness with a "will."
Conclusion:  Since a consciousness does not hold metaphysical primacy over reality and it is not possible for a consciousness to create/change existents through "will" alone, such a god as defined cannot exist.*
*For more insight on the primacy of existence and the above argument, check out Dawson Bethrick's website/blog, Incinerating Presuppositionalism.

No comments:

Post a Comment